Timing The Bottom

discretionary spending

If the last three days haven’t been tough enough on investors, we have a new week with new reports you should be aware of.  So without further ado, let’s get started.

Tuesday – PPI Demand.  This is the Producers Price Index, which measures the price changes for goods, services, and construction.  

The year-over-year consensus is an 11% increase, which would match the y-o-y increase we had last month.  However, the PPI number is set to increase month-over-month from a .5% gain to a .8% gain, showing prices are continually rising.  

If you remove food and energy from the PPI, the consensus is an 8.7% increase in prices year-over-year this month, but it would show a number slightly lower than last month’s y-o-y report of 8.8%.  

Wednesday – Fed Day! First, we have retail sales in the morning.  Retail sales are supposed to come in with an anemic month-over-month gain of 0.1%, a far cry from last month’s .9% reading.  Most of the decline can be attributed to vehicles and gas sales.  

The Fed is expected to announce a .5% hike in interest rates again on Wednesday.  That has been planned and mostly priced in, but after that, all bets are off.  Bigger rate hikes could be in the cards in the coming months.  There is an off-chance that they raise rates by .75% to show they are being aggressive towards out-of-control consumer prices.  

Thursday – Housing Starts and Jobless Claims.  The housing market is set to report weakening numbers while the jobless claims are set to decrease from last week’s highest reading since January 15th of this year.  

Friday – Powell speaks (pre-market).  There’s also the Industrial Production report, which is set to show a slowdown in industrial manufacturing.

Despite the number of reports out this week, all eyes will be on the Fed on Wednesday.  The market may rally on some indication the Fed is going to be aggressive in dealing with inflation, but so far we’ve seen a rally on the day of the announcement and then the market gives back the gains over the following days.  

Today I want to talk about oil and discretionary spending.  There’s a point when consumers will say enough is enough and stop spending their hard-earned money.  Right now consumers are dealing with higher interest payments on credit cards, homes, new car purchases, and more.  If the economy goes into a recession or stagflation, will the jobs market also fall apart?

As consumers become uncertain of economic conditions, they put off major purchases and start to watch their pocketbooks more closely.  As the economy unwinds, crude oil prices also collapse.

So, if that’s the case, can we look at discretionary spending and see if we can figure out when oil will start to fall and when we might see a bottom in the market?  Of course, this time is slightly different due to the war in Ukraine, but it’s worth a look.

Keep reading to see if discretionary spending and the price of oil are correlated and if we can pick a market bottom.

Let’s travel back to 2007 for a moment.  This chart compares the US Consumer Discretionary ETF (IYC) against the Crude Oil futures contract.  The IYC is on top and crude oil is the purple line below it.

discretionary spending

As you can see, discretionary spending was flat from March to July and started to sell off.  Meanwhile, the price of crude continued to accelerate, even at a parabolic rate heading into its peak in July of 2008.  

There was a disconnect between consumer spending and the price of oil, and eventually, that led to a crash in the oil market.  

The price of oil peaked at around $140 and fell to less than $40 by the start of 2009 (purple line in the chart below).  As the economy was going through the housing crisis, discretionary spending continued to pull back as well (upper chart).  The IYC lost 54% from peak to trough.

discretionary spending

Then the market hit a bottom and both discretionary spending and the price of oil started the climb up, together, in lockstep.  

Ok, so now let’s go back to the future.

Here’s where we are now. Look familiar? 

I’m not sure we’re going to make a bottom until we see a major pullback in oil.  Last time it took about 6 months for oil to go from peak to trough.  That means we could see discretionary spending keep heading lower for another 6 months before the two charts go back to traveling back up in lockstep.  

Does it have to take 6 months?  Of course not!  And maybe this time will be different, but the charts are too similar to ignore.

The other interesting thing on that chart is that the IYC is now below the pre-pandemic high. 

There are a couple of support lines on the IYC chart, but we’re showing that the sector has more downside potential.  

Here’s some fun math.  Remember I mentioned that the IYC lost 54%?  If the same thing happens this time from the high of $87.51, we’re looking at a bottom around $40.25.  We’re currently trading at $56.85.  And look at the chart below.  Where is that bottom line of support? Right around $40.  

You can trade this ETF, or the XLY, or take a deeper look into the companies that make up the sector to see which ones are more likely to lead the group lower.  

If you have any questions, comments, or anything we can help with, reach us at any time.

Here are three ways you can protect your portfolio from market volatility and a potentially larger move to the downside.

Hedge Your Portfolio

You can liquidate your portfolio and go into cash, but that may cause tax consequences some of you are not prepared to take on yet. If you don’t want to go to cash, you can hedge using inverse ETFs.

An inverse ETF for a specific sector gains in value if the stocks in the ETF decrease in value.  The ETF performance acts inversely to the stocks it holds in the portfolio.

Here’s an example from the Direxion Daily Semiconductor Bear 3X Shares (SOXS) ETF.  This is a triple-leveraged bear ETF, which means it gains/loses 3x the amount of the daily move of the semiconductor industry.  If the semis move down 1% in a day, this ETF will gain 3%.  Likewise, if the semis gain 1% in a day, this ETF will lose 3% in a day.

protect your portfolio

Now, look at a chart of the semiconductor sector below.  Can you see how the charts sort of mirror one another?  As the semiconductor sector decreases in value (lower chart), the inverse ETF (upper chart increases in value). 

Hedge Your Portfolio

If you’re not experienced with triple leveraged ETFs, I’d start off with a single leveraged bear ETF, but try to find one that is best suited to protect the stocks that you’re trying to protect.  


If you mostly have a blue-chip portfolio, find an inverse ETF that will gain value if blue-chips go down.


Wait, why would I do this?  Don’t I walk away flat in the end?  My stocks go down and the inverse ETF goes up, so doesn’t that mean I’m breaking even?


In this case, hedging is similar to insurance.  I’m not trying to make money from placing a hedge, but I am trying to protect what I already have.  You can also skew your portfolio to be bullish or bearish.  It doesn’t have to be flat.


You can buy and sell inverse ETFs like you would any other stock.  If you think the semis are going down next week, place a hedge, and then take it off a week later if you think the semis are going back up.


Trade Short

For those who have the accounts that allow it, you can sell shares short.  Make sure you fully understand the concept of short selling before you place this type of trade.  Essentially, you profit when the price of the stock goes down.

You know me, I like scans.  I put together a formula looking at the SP500 stocks and their performance over various time frames and devised a worst-performers list.  

These stocks have been absolute stinkers lately and are the latest on my worst-performers scan.  Will they continue to sink?

I don’t know if these will be lower a month from now, but last month I ran the same scan, and selling the five worst would have returned a 9.03% gain in a month.  Not all five were winners, but the bottom five as a portfolio came out ahead.

Buy Top Performing Stocks

Similar to short selling the worst performers, you can also build a portfolio of the best performers.  This current list shows that energy is still the top performer.  These collectively gained over 91%, or 18% average per stock since last month.

top stocks to buy

While I’ve created a custom scan to help me, you can start by looking at a simple SP500 6-month best performers and worst performers list readily available on several financial websites.  

A portfolio of buying the top five best 6-month performers gained about 11% over this past month.

A portfolio of short-selling the worst five 6-month performers gained 5% over this past month.

Collectively, those 10 stocks returned 16% last month using an equally weighted portfolio.

Do some backtests and see what fits your trading style.

Past performance is not indicative of future results, but I want to give you three ideas of what you can do to hedge against volatility.  

If you have any questions, comments, or anything we can help with, reach us at any time.


Guest Writer, Filthy Rich, Dirt Poor
Editor, Wealthy Investor Society

Receive the latest news

Subscribe To Our Daily Newsletter

Get notified about new articles, special events, training, and much more

Like What You See?

Leave your info below to get more options and trading ideas to your inbox

Yes, send me news to my inbox.